Summit 2009: Summary Of Keynote Presentations May 6, 2009
Following are highlights from the keynote speakers at FEI’s Summit Conference held May 3-5, 2009 at the Gaylord Texan Hotel in Grapevine, Texas.
Building Investor Confidence and the New Financial Landscape
Duncan L. Neiderauer, Chief Executive Officer, NYSE Euronext
In a sign of the times, Duncan Neiderauer opened Financial Executives International’s Summit conference on May 4, 2009 commenting on “Investor Confidence and the New Financial Landscape.” Noting he’s not an economist, he described an economic crisis that to him, in contrast to what many are characterizing as “unprecedented,” is “not unprecedented.”
In the United States – with its free-market philosophy – we get bubbles every eight-to-10 years, he said. What he believes is unprecedented, however, is the stimulus the U.S. (and global governments) are “throwing at the problem.”
What governments are doing collectively, he said, indicates “we’re on the road to recovery.”
However, patience is needed – “something the U.S. is not known for,” he said.
Did he see this coming? A resounding “No!”
But, he insists, he’s optimistic for a recovery within one year. The March and April equities markets uptick, he said, felt more like a “trader’s market than an investor’s market,” and that he’s “looking for an investor’s market.
History tells us, continued Neiderauer, that “crises all give rise to opportunities.
He negated as “myth,” the perception that Wall Street and Main Street are “disconnected,” saying that Main Street business cannot run without fully functional markets.
Initial public offerings with NYSE Euronext in 2008, as expected, were down significantly, but two recent IPOs in April – Rosetta Stone and Bridgepoint Education – are doing fine. He noted pricing as possible issues for unsuccessful IPOs. “The last thing you want to do [when you go public] is to miss quarters one, two and three.”
And some advice to those companies considering going public in the near future: Ready your documents, “be poised and ready, as the market may give an opportunity to go.”
He also advised the U.S. to guard against protectionism, or what he’s termed “localization,” In lieu of globalization and to thus not let globalization become the new casualty.
He sprinkled his presentation with macro and micro solutions for solving the current problems and restoring investor confidence, noting that transparency and accountability are key. One micro reform: Cognizant that regulation is coming – and changing – he’s keen on regulating by activity (for example, AIG is in five businesses so the insurance industry should not be its only regulator).
On a single set of global accounting standards, Neidermauer expects the U.S. will move in that direction and is determined that such a move to International Financial Reporting Standards “doesn’t become the next Sarbanes-Oxley.”
Themes on the Economy
Diane Swonk, Chief Economist and Senior Managing Director, Mesirow Financial
Diane Swonk described the U.S. economy in the fourth quarter of 2008 as “in freefall and technically in [a] recession.”
Now in May 2009, we’re not in freefall any longer. In fact, the parachute is open, she said; but she doesn’t know when – or where – we’re going to land. For certain, however, she expects on landing we’ll find an economy that is fundamentally different from what we’ve become accustomed to.
Economist Swonk rattled off numbers associated with consumers, among which included three categories of spending that are currently strong: alcohol, condoms and guns, and that the savings rate has risen to 4 percent. The housing market, she said, which has been a drag on the U.S. economy for four years, has now fallen so low it “almost has nowhere to go.”
However, she expects the rate to stabilize by next year, and noted sales of foreclosures were up – perhaps due to the federal government’s $8,000 credit for home purchases.
For those who insist on comparing the present economy to the Great Depression, Swonk noted 25 percent unemployment – in contrast to today’s 8.5 percent – and said that while it may now be “depressing, it’s not the Depression.”
Separately, on employment, she noted that her firm just hired 50 people – from the ashes of Bear Stearns and Lehman, and advised firms needing to find good people: “It’s an extraordinary time to grab talent.”
She expects technology and the next generation to be different, and she’s optimistic that we’ll ultimately cross 10,000. “if not this year, then in 2010.”
Indeed Swonk said of Monday’s significant upward-market close: “Who’d of thought we’d cheer 8,400?”
The End of the World as We Know It, and What Finance Can Do About It
Chris Ballinger, Chief Financial Officer, Toyota Financial Services
Chris Ballinger admitted that the title of his speech was dramatic, but then noted he began his CFO post at Toyota Financial Services last year – on a day when the Dow Jones Industrial Average was below 6,600 and big U.S. banks were having “shotgun” marriages.
There have been some changes since then, and he said he sees some recent signs of recovery, but warns of some rough waters ahead nonetheless. This could come from results of bank stress tests (where getting capital is still an issue) and liquidity remains an issue for many.
In his compelling presentation, economist Ballinger drew upon history and former great economists and some colleagues and peers to pepper his comments on key economic terms – as applied to today’s issues – such as “principal agent” and “asysemetric Information.”
Referring to principal agent, he said Warren Buffet described it best in saying, “Nobody ever washed a rental car!” In other words, much of the financial crisis was based on those involved having ”too little skin in the game.”
Among his comments on the role of Finance in governance and improving governance in a broad sense, he said to include: risk assessment, incentives and rewards, transfer pricing, incentives and rewards, solving principal agent problems, decentralizing centralized information using robust networks, transparent expectation and more.
He also described how some of the famed Toyota’s pricing models are responding to the financial crisis.
Ballinger noted that lending has become better recently and that Toyota is “flush” with cash – having borrowed $16 billion in the last few months.
In response to a question, he said his biggest problem as a CFO is that while he can access capital now, it’s expensive. But it’s not that expensive for competitors in government programs. Thus, according to Ballinger, “we compete against bank lenders and securitization programs and everyone [else] has access to those programs.”
Toyota has gone from a Triple-A rating to Double-AA, but even that is not as good as a government guarantee. But, he did stress significant improvement in the last month overall.
View From the C-Suite
Zanny Minton-Beddoes, U.S. Economics Editor, The Economist; Richard G. Lindner, Senior Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer; Patrick Mulva, Vice President & Controller, Exxon Mobil Corp.; Laura Wright, Senior Vice President & Chief Financial Officer, Southwest Airlines Co.
Zanny Minton-Beddoes led a lively discussion among three senior finance chiefs of some of U.S. icons on how they are coping with and planning during the current economy.
“Even by British standards of understatement,” said Minton-Beddoes, we’re in the midst of the longest, worst [deepest] global recession when the world economy will shrink for the first time. She asked each panelist to discuss what it means for their organization. Overall – as would be expected – all three are shoring up cash, looking to cost-cutting, labor-cost reductions, increasing risk management and planning for the long term.
The lively discussion also ranged from hedging (Southwest Airlines), energy policy and potential carbon taxes and/or cap and trade legislation (Exxon Mobil) and the nature of AT&T’s competition in the future.
Some key points:
Laura Wright characterized the situation as “the most difficult credit environment I’ve ever seen,” and explained that Southwest Airlines is a cyclical business, that lags both in the beginning of an economic downturn as well as coming out of it. The firm is particularly feeling the pinch of U.S. businesses, and, while running record load factors – planes are filled with leisure travelers, not the coveted business travelers.
The firm’s plans assume “we will stay down for the rest of the year,” said Wright, as even when the economy picks up, “it will take time for business travel to come back.”
Wright said the firm is used to dealing with credit cycles, but that in this downturn “all the rules were broken; what we knew ceased to exist.”
The environment, however, has caused her firm to increase risk assessments, contingency planning and go deeper to “think about the other bad things that can happen.”
Too, she indicated Southwest has become “more conservative” and is “getting cash when we can.”
Richard G. Lindner said the economic weakness was first felt by AT&T early last year as businesses cut back on spending, causing sales to fall. Confidence, he said, “fell off a cliff” in the latter part of the third quarter, causing deep employment and less business travel – which was visible in his firm’s networks.
As to recovery, while he says he wouldn’t say there are “green shoots” he indicated the “seedlings are planted.”
One of Lindner’s biggest concerns is that the “regulation pendulum swings back to more regulation of operations.” Of regulations, he believes that “while they may be well-intended, they often have unintended consequences,” and he cites the Telecommunications Act of 1996 that resulted in less investment by those who had capital. The current uncertainty – new faces in Washington – makes it a difficult time to get things done – such as mergers, he said.
Patrick Mulva said his industry has been on “quite a ride the last three years,” as the price of crude oil jumped to more than $140 per barrel, then down to $40-$50 per barrel. “It’s too early to tell” where it will go, he said, and that Exxon runs its business by having a disciplined focus on the long-term. \
“How do we see the world in 15-to-20 years?” He expects to see economic growth at 3 percent over that time, and said “to provide affordable energy, we have to stay focused long term and ensure we keep investing – and that’s what we’re doing.”
Mulva noted that Exxon is “hiring in all disciplines.”
* * * *
Upcoming Events Learn more about FEI's upcoming conferences and webcasts.
-- Ellen M. Heffes
Editor-in-Chief, Financial Executive
|